We studied the evolution of capillary bridges between nominally flat plates undergoing multiple cycles of compression and stretching in experiments and simulations. We varied the distance between the plates in small increments to study the full evolution of the bridge shape. Experiments show that contact angle hysteresis determines the shape of the bridge. In sliding drops, hysteresis can be modeled using a contact angle-dependent resistive force (F) over tilde (R) applied at the contact line. We developed a model that accurately captures the evolution of the bridge shape by combining (F) over tilde (R) and constrained energy minimization. Unlike previous work, this allows for both complete and partial contact line pinning. We also explored the effect of using nonparallel plates. The asymmetry in the bridge shape causes the movement of the center of mass of the bridge and can be explained by contact angle hysteresis. We find that even a slight misalignment between the flat plates can have a measurable effect.